Is auto_ptr deprecated?

  1. Will auto_ptr be deprecated in incoming C++ standard?
  2. Should unique_ptr be used for ownership transfer instead of shared_ptr?
  3. If unique_ptr is not in the standard, then do I need to use shared_ptr instead?

Answers


UPDATE: This answer was written in 2010 and as anticipated std::auto_ptr has been deprecated. The advice is entirely valid.

In C++0x std::auto_ptr will be deprecated in favor of std::unique_ptr. The choice of smart pointer will depend on your use case and your requirements, with std::unique_ptr with move semantics for single ownership that can be used inside containers (using move semantics) and std::shared_ptr when ownership is shared.

You should try to use the smart pointer that best fits the situation, choosing the correct pointer type provides other programmers with insight into your design.


Yes, as of today auto_ptr will be deprecated in C++0x and you should use unique_ptr instead. From the latest draft standard (n3035), section D.9

The class template auto_ptr is deprecated. [ Note: The class template unique_ptr (20.9.10) provides a better solution. —end note ]

Until the standard is ratified, it's always possible that the committee will revise this decision although I feel that is unlikely for this decision.


Not only auto_ptr is deprecated in C++11 (D.10, page 1228), it will also be deleted in a future version of C++:

Adopted N4190, and actually removed (not just deprecated) several archaic things from the C++ standard library, including auto_ptr, bind1st/bind2nd, ptr_fun/mem_fun/mem_fun_ref, random_shuffle, and a few more. Those are now all removed from the draft C++17 standard library and will not be part of future portable C++.

Another document about it: Programming Language C++, Library Evolution Working Group - Document N4190, if you want more information.

You can convert any code using auto_ptr automaticaly, by using unique_ptr instead:

Any code using auto_ptr can be mechanically converted to using unique_ptr, with move() inserted whenever auto_ptr was being "copied".


No, it isn't deprecated. It may be, if C++0x ever gets accepted. And it will realistically always be supported. I don't believe that any deprecated feature has ever been dropped from real-world C++ implementations.


Need Your Help

How to generate random data for testing database performance?

mysql testing

I have created a test table in MySQL and would like to insert 10 million rows with randomly generated data. How to do this random generation process? Is there any predefined method in MySQL or is t...

create index clause on table variable

sql sql-server tsql sql-server-2012 sql-server-2014

I need to create an Index on two columns (within a table variable) which do not form unique key.