Including FSharp.Core in a C# project: resolving type collisions

I'm using some F# types (Matrix et al) from C# and so I need to reference the FSharp.Core assembly in my C# project. So far, so good.

However, there are apparently some types defined in mscorlib.dll (v4) which are "duplicated" in FSharp.Core (v2), like System.Tuple and System.IObservable. I can't understand why this is in .Net 4. Matt Ellis specifically said they would be removed in his MSDN article:

One language suffering that [duplication] problem was F#, which previously had defined its own tuple type in FSharp.Core.dll but will now use the tuple added in Microsoft .NET Framework 4.

I'm ready to look past this particular unseemly duplication if I could just specify which one I want to use in my C# program, however. When I try to use the System.Tuple type, for example, I get the following C# compiler error:

Error 2 The type 'System.Tuple' exists in both 'c:\Program Files (x86)\Reference Assemblies\Microsoft\Framework.NETFramework\v4.0\Profile\Client\mscorlib.dll' and 'c:\Program Files (x86)\Reference Assemblies\Microsoft\FSharp\2.0\Runtime\v2.0\FSharp.Core.dll'

The way around this, apparently, is a switch on the C# compiler command line which aliases the type:

csc.exe MyType.cs /reference:System.Tuple`2=mscorlib.dll /reference:FSharp.Core.dll

However, I can't find a way to get Visual Studio to send this parameter to the C# compiler.

Anyone have a solution to this?


You need to reference the 4.0 version of the F# runtime. This version corresponds with the 4.0 version of mscorlib and does not have the conflicting types. They will be in this directory

C:\Program Files (x86)\Reference Assemblies\Microsoft\FSharp\2.0\Runtime\v4.0

You can resolve conflicts by using C# assembly aliases and qualifying source assembly explicitly in C# code: for example if you have Tuple type defined both in F# assembly and in you libraries.

Need Your Help

What are the factors to decide between using Core Data versus rolling out a custom model?

cocoa macos core-data

There might be applications that are not suited for Core Data - image manipulation programs like Photoshop or Gimp for example. But for applications that are suited for Core Data, say Address Book or

generate dependencies for a makefile for a project in C/C++

c++ c makefile dependencies

I have a project that has a makefile with broken dependencies. Is there any best known way to generate a list of dependencies for the project that I can use in the makefile, other than examining e...