Qt Signals and Slot connected twice... what happens?

What happens if the same signal and slot is connected twice?

How is the mechanism handled?

Answers


A few weeks ago, we had an intern accidentally connect a signal to a slot more than once. The idea was that under one condition, you'd have the slot connected to the signal, and under another condition you'd disconnect it. When you changed modes, you'd do the appropriate work.

Well, he forgot to to disconnect when appropriate. So every time you changed modes, you had a new connection to the slot.

The end result? 1 connection == 1 call to slot. 2 connections == 2 calls to slot. 3 connections == 3 calls to slot, etc. These calls happened "simultaneously" (I know in actuality they did not since they are on the same event thread, but what I mean was all calls were processed in succession).

As @Job points out in one of his comments (he deserves credit, so please do not upvote me for his work), Qt::UniqueConnection will prevent this issue.


Usually bad things. It's perfectly acceptable to connect the slot twice or even more times but when the signal gets fired your slot will be called for each connection you made which is probably not what you want.

Note that it is not necessarily wrong to have multiple connections. There are (probably) perfectly valid uses for it. They are quite rare, I certainly can't think of any time I've used it as a feature. All the situations I can recall where there was a multiple connection turned out to be a bug rather than intended.


The slot is executed multiple times (as others said already).

Some more notes:

  • In former times, the pattern for "connect exactly once" in cases where there might have been a connection before, was to first call disconnect and then connect to enforce exactly one connection.
  • Now, since 4.6, there is also the more elegant Qt::UniqueConnection, see http://doc.qt.io/qt-5/qt.html#ConnectionType-enum

Need Your Help

How to Clone an Eclipse Workspace

eclipse workspace

I am wondering how to create new clean Eclipse workspace but having all settings from an existing one.

Error "unknown delivery tag" occurs when i try ack messages to RabbitMQ using pika (python)

python message-queue rabbitmq pika

I want process messages in few threads but i'm getting error during execute this code: